A worker opens a tenant’s eviction notice and wants to know what is wrong with it. Here is what a good tool does, in the order the work happens, with a question for you at each step.
Answer the questions on the parts you know from your own practice. The Commons team reads every answer, fixes what the list gets wrong, and takes the harder questions to the cohort working on this area.
The worker has a notice in front of them, often a photograph taken on a phone, sometimes a clean PDF from a landlord’s attorney, and sometimes several pages stapled together. Before anything is checked, the tool has to be able to read it, and to say when it cannot.
What a good tool does
Take a notice as a PDF or as a photograph, and say plainly when a file is too big rather than failing in silence.
Pull the text out of a notice that was generated on a computer.
Warn the worker when it cannot read the page at all, which happens with a scan or a photograph that carries no text.
Check that the document is the kind of notice it expects before it runs, so a utility bill or a blank page does not get a full analysis.
What it must never do
Come back with a clean result when the truth is that it could not read the page.
What do these notices actually look like where you work?
Answer this
Part 2
Checking the notice against the rules
This is the part that looks like legal work. The tool checks the notice against the rules that govern it, one defect at a time, and each check is written down in plain language so a lawyer can read it and change it.
What a good tool does
Check each defect against a written rule for that defect, which states what is being checked, which statute governs it, and what counts as a problem.
Flag charges beyond the rent, such as a late fee, which cannot appear in a pay or quit notice.
Flag a notice that does not say clearly who to pay, where, and how to reach them.
Flag a missing or vague cure period, so a notice that does not give a specific number of days does not pass.
Count the days the way the rule counts them, including court days rather than calendar days where that is what the rule requires, and leave out holidays.
Flag a demand for more than the rent owed, or for a period further back than the statute allows.
Raise language that is borderline rather than letting it pass, because a defense raised and then rejected costs less than one that is missed.
Put proof of service in front of the worker as a question to follow up, and leave the answer to the person.
Work out which county and city rules apply from the property address, and say which ones it used.
Check the notice against the local ordinances as well as the state statute, including just cause and rent control rules where they apply.
Raise a question where the local law is unsettled, such as a court taking the position that a notice period conflicts with a federal act, and give the authority on both sides rather than picking a side.
Apply the extra notice requirements that come with a subsidized tenancy.
Apply the rules for a mobile home tenancy, which are not the general landlord and tenant rules.
Which defects does this list miss?
Answer this
Part 3
Quoting the words behind every flag
A flag with nothing behind it is worth very little, because the worker has to check it anyway. Everything the tool says has to be traceable to the words on the page.
What a good tool does
Attach the exact words from the notice to every flag, and tell the worker when the quote does not match the document.
Record what was checked and found clean, rather than only what was raised.
Show the reasoning behind each verdict, including any date arithmetic it did.
Use a confidence score only to send something for review, never to hide a finding or reorder the list.
What it must never do
Invent a quote, or show words that do not appear in the notice.
What would you need to see beside a flag before you trusted it enough to act on it?
Answer this
Part 4
Interviewing the tenant
A notice shows only some of the defenses a tenant may have. They are in what happened between the tenant and the landlord, so the tool has to take the worker into an interview rather than stopping at the document.
What a good tool does
Walk the worker through defenses that never appear in the document itself.
Cover habitability, retaliation, and any rent cap protection that applies.
Ask what the landlord did after the notice, including whether they took rent afterwards or said the tenant could stay.
Let the worker skip a question, go back, change an answer, and jump ahead, which is how an experienced interviewer actually works.
Ask for a written reason whenever a defense is raised, so that raising one is a deliberate act.
What do you always ask a tenant that is nowhere in the notice?
Answer this
Part 5
Producing the court response
The work ends in a document the court will accept, with the defenses in it. The tool fills in what it already knows, and the worker checks every line of it.
What a good tool does
Fill in the court response from the notice analysis and from the interview answers.
Ask the worker to confirm each field before producing anything.
Hold the response until the defense review is finished.
Keep everything the worker has entered, so nothing is lost when they edit a field or change tabs and come back.
Write what it pulled from the notice and the complaint into the case management system the organization already prepares answers in, rather than making somebody retype it.
Carry the defense questions the answer form itself asks, and put only the ones that matter for the defenses being raised in front of the worker.
What gets that form rejected at the counter in your court?
Answer this
Part 6
Attorney review and sign off
The tool assists a trained worker who is supervised by an attorney. It is not advice to a tenant, and it does not file anything.
What a good tool does
Require a supervising attorney to sign off before a response leaves the organization.
Show the reviewer what was raised and what was cleared, side by side, with the reason attached.
Say in the product who it is for and how the supervision works.
Present what it produces as an analysis for a supervised worker to review.
What it must never do
Let a clean result read as confirmation that the notice is good, when it means only that nothing was detected.
Be open to anyone, because a landlord’s attorney could run a draft notice through it and cure the defects before serving it.
File anything, or advise the tenant directly.
Take instructions from the uploaded notice, so that text inside a document cannot change a rule or a verdict.
Where would you draw the line between what a worker can send out and what an attorney has to see first?
Answer this
Part 7
Handling the tenant’s information
A notice carries a name, an address, and often an income. The organization has to be able to say where that goes and how long it stays.
What a good tool does
Hold the tenant’s details for the session only, or else behind a login with a retention rule written down.
Collect nothing the task does not need, including no demographic information.
Write down where client data goes, including to any outside model, and have the partner organization approve it.
Give workers named accounts, and remove both the access and the stored intake when somebody leaves.
What would your organization need to know about where this information goes?
Answer this
Part 8
Using it at the help desk
The work happens at a help desk with a queue of people waiting. A tool that is correct and slow does not get used twice.
What a good tool does
Connect each flag to its place in the document in both directions, so selecting one highlights the other.
List the defects in the order they appear in the notice.
Make the highlights visible without covering the text.
Make it obvious whether an action means reviewed or means raising a defense.
Handle a notice that runs to several pages, with the annotations findable on every page.
Say what can be typed where, so a long answer does not lose somebody’s work.
What would make this unusable in your office on a Monday morning?
Answer this
Part 9
Keeping the rules current
The statute changes, a court reads a rule a new way, and a tool that was right last year starts producing wrong answers quietly. Somebody has to be able to fix it without a developer.
What a good tool does
Keep the checks in plain language, so a legal collaborator can change them without touching code.
Version the rules and the list of defects, and record which version produced each verdict.
Publish a scored test set with the results for each defect, and name who labeled it.
Have an expert settle the cases where labelers disagreed, so the reported accuracy is real.
Who would keep these rules current where you are?
Answer this
What happens to what you write
Every note comes to the Commons team. We read it against the detailed agenda, correct what is wrong, and publish a new version saying what changed. The questions that need practitioners to argue them out go to the cohort for that area.
A note about one line is as useful as a note that adds a whole step. If what you know is the day-counting rule in your county, write about that.
The two agendas for this workflow
You are reading this one
Step-by-step agenda
This is the first round, and it collects what the people who do this work say a tool has to do, in the order the work happens and in plain words. Read it to argue with it, to correct it, and to say what your jurisdiction needs.