Somebody calls a legal help line and an AI system answers. Here is what a good one does, in the order a call happens, with a question for you at each step.
Answer the questions on the parts you know from your own practice. The Commons team reads every answer, fixes what the list gets wrong, and takes the harder questions to the cohort working on this area.
Somebody dials the number on a flyer, or the hotline forwards the call after hours. Before any of the legal work, the call has to be answered, stay up, and survive the things that go wrong on a phone line.
What a good system does
Answer quickly on the published number, and take calls that the phone system the organization already runs forwards to it.
Hold several callers at once without dropping any of them at normal volume.
Keep the audio clear enough to follow from the greeting to the end of the call.
Let somebody who was cut off pick the call back up, using a reference number and the number they called from.
Stay on the line when something inside the system fails, play a message the caller can act on, and offer a callback.
Log every call with its time, its length, and how it ended, and manage a number that calls over and over.
What happens today when a call to your hotline drops?
Answer this
Part 2
Telling the caller what this is
The caller has to know they are talking to a machine, that it is not their lawyer, and what happens to what they say. This part comes before a single question about their problem.
What a good system does
Say at the start, clearly, that the caller is speaking with an AI system.
Read the statement that the system is not a lawyer before collecting anything.
Ask for a spoken yes before continuing, and record that answer with the time.
Explain in plain words what happens to the caller’s information.
Say the confidentiality line again before the sections on safety, immigration, and money.
Tell the caller when somebody will follow up.
Offer a person at every stage, so the caller can leave the AI conversation at any point.
Follow the recording consent law of every state the line takes calls from, and deliver the whole consent script in the language the caller chose.
What does your organization have to say at the start of a call?
Answer this
Part 3
Taking the caller’s details
The details that make the rest of the call useful are the ones most likely to go wrong over the phone, including a name nobody spells the same way twice.
What a good system does
Take the caller’s name and read the spelling back to them.
Take a phone number and read the digits back.
Take a full mailing address, with the street, the city, the state, and the postal code.
Take a date of birth, however the caller says it.
Collect an unusual name letter by letter, and hand the call to a person after 2 failed attempts rather than making the caller repeat it again.
Notice when somebody is calling on behalf of another person, and record the relationship and whether that person agreed to it.
Keep the callback details before any call ends, and offer a slower speaking pace to a caller who wants one.
What it must never do
Let an adverse party’s name overwrite the record of the person applying for help.
What goes wrong when your staff take these details by phone?
Answer this
Part 4
Finding the legal problem
A caller often does not open with the legal issue. They open with what happened, and the system has to find the issue inside the story without cutting the story off.
What a good system does
Ask what happened with open questions, rather than forcing a category first.
Classify the problem using the shared list of legal issues, and agree with an expert often enough that staff can rely on it. The detailed agenda sets the number.
Record the ambiguity and flag it for a person when a problem could sit in more than one category, rather than picking one and moving on.
Find the legal issue when the caller does not know that what happened to them is one.
Record every issue the caller raises, not only the first.
Capture the whole story and send it for a person to classify when the problem crosses several areas of law.
Redirect gently when a caller wants to tell everything, and still keep the call near its normal length.
How do callers describe this problem in their own words?
Answer this
Part 5
Screening for eligibility
Screening decides whether the caller gets help here or a referral somewhere else, so it has to be right, and it has to be something staff can change when the income limits change.
What a good system does
Screen income against the organization’s own income limits with rules rather than with a model, and screen for the area served and the kind of case.
Say that every eligibility answer is tentative and that a person will review it.
Record what the caller said and flag it when their answers contradict each other, rather than forcing a yes or a no.
Let staff update the income tables without a developer.
Ask follow-up questions about income and property when something in the call suggests there is more.
Know what each issue area has capacity for, and use that in deciding where the call goes.
Who sets the eligibility rules in your organization?
Answer this
Part 6
Safety, crisis, and sensitive disclosures
A caller describes being hurt, or goes quiet, or starts crying. This is the part of the call where a system that handles it badly does real harm, and missing a disclosure is the worst failure in the whole workflow.
What a good system does
Notice domestic violence whether the caller says it plainly or talks around it.
Change the conversation once that happens, offer safety resources, and stop pressing for personal details.
Notice a caller in crisis, stop the routine intake, and run the crisis protocol straight away.
Handle a disclosure about immigration status by reassuring the caller about confidentiality, making no eligibility decision, and flagging the call.
Explain why a question is being asked when a caller will not answer it, apply no pressure, and either continue or pass the call to a person.
Slow down with a caller in distress, say that they have been heard, and offer a person.
What it must never do
Refuse to continue because the subject is abuse. A safety disclosure needs a helpful answer, not a content refusal.
What does your hotline do today when a caller discloses abuse or is in crisis?
Answer this
Part 7
Checking for conflicts
The organization may already represent the person on the other side. The check has to happen before a record exists, and the caller must learn nothing from it.
What a good system does
Run a soft conflict check against the case management system before creating a case record.
Flag a possible conflict for a person, and neither confirm nor deny it to the caller.
Verify a returning caller on more than one thing, such as a reference number with a date of birth or the last digits of a phone number.
What it must never do
Tell any caller anything about an existing client or an existing case.
How does your conflict check work today?
Answer this
Part 8
Routing and referral
The end of the call is a decision about where this person goes, and a referral that goes nowhere is worse than none.
What a good system does
Send an eligible caller to the right team or queue.
Give a caller the organization cannot serve a specific, current referral rather than a general information line.
Hand a caller off by name when their issue area is full.
Notice a call that is not an intake call, including a complaint or somebody on the other side of a case, and redirect it without starting intake.
Which of your referrals have gone stale?
Answer this
Part 9
The intake record staff receive
The call is only useful if the person who picks the case up next does not have to ring the caller back for the basics.
What a good system does
Write a narrative summary detailed enough that staff do not call the person back for things they already said.
Fill the structured fields in the case management system accurately, and put each one in the right place.
Record what the system classified and how confident it was.
Carry every flag into the record, including safety, crisis, conflict, and capacity, so each one starts the workflow it belongs to.
Keep the transcript, or a pointer to the recording, so staff can read what was actually said.
Create the record through the case management system itself, with no re-typing.
What does your staff need in an intake record before they will trust it?
Answer this
Part 10
Staying out of legal advice
A caller will ask what they should do. The system has to be useful without answering that question, and it has to hold the line when the caller pushes.
What a good system does
Decline a request for advice however it arrives, whether it is a direct question, a hypothetical, a claim that somebody said it was fine, or the same question asked again.
Log every time it declined, and why, so staff can see it.
What it must never do
Give legal advice, predict what will happen in a case, or interpret the law for the caller.
What phrasing have you found that stays on the right side of the line in your state?
Answer this
Part 11
Serving callers in other languages
Language is where intake systems quietly fail, because the call completes and the record looks fine while the caller understood half of it.
What a good system does
Let the caller choose a language at the start, by voice or by keypad.
Hold the whole conversation in that language, including the consent script.
Reach the same completion and accuracy as the English calls. The detailed agenda sets how close that has to be.
How does your line handle the languages your callers need?
Answer this
What happens to what you write
Every note comes to the Commons team. We read it against the detailed agenda, correct what is wrong, and publish a new version saying what changed. The questions that need practitioners to argue them out go to the cohort for that area.
A note about one line is as useful as a note that adds a whole step. If what you know is how your hotline handles a caller in crisis, write about that.
The two agendas for this workflow
You are reading this one
Step-by-step agenda
This is the first round, and it collects what the people who do this work say a tool has to do, in the order the work happens and in plain words. Read it to argue with it, to correct it, and to say what your jurisdiction needs.